Rubber vs. Elastic vs. Leather: How to Choose the Right Watch Strap

The right strap can completely change a watch — its character, its comfort, and how often it ends up on your wrist. At Artisan Watch Co. we make three main families of strap, and each suits a different mood and moment. Here’s how to choose.

Rubber straps: built for everyday

If you wear one watch most days, a rubber strap is hard to beat. Moulded from premium high-density rubber, it’s soft against the skin, water-resistant, and shrugs off knocks, sweat and sun. That makes it a natural fit for dive and GMT watches — think Submariner, GMT-Master II and Daytona — and for anyone with an active routine. Prefer a more secure, adjustable feel? Our deployant-buckle rubber straps add a folding clasp. Browse the full range of rubber straps.

Elastic loop straps: comfort and colour

Our signature single-pass elastic loop straps slide on in seconds with no buckle to fuss over. They’re feather-light, endlessly comfortable, and add an easy pop of colour — perfect for weekends, summer and travel. If you like to swap looks often without thinking about it, this is the one.

Saffiano leather straps: refined and dressy

When you want to dress a watch up, Saffiano leather is the answer. Its signature cross-hatch texture resists scratches and holds its shape, giving a smart, understated finish that works from the office to dinner. It’s the most formal of the three, and the easiest way to make a sports watch feel a little more considered.

Getting the fit right

Whichever material you choose, fit is everything — a strap should sit flush against the case with no gaps. The number that matters is your lug width, in millimetres. Not sure what yours is? Use our Find Your Fit tool or check the size guide, and we’ll point you to the exact width and the styles made for your watch.

So, which should you choose?

  • Daily wear, water, sport: rubber.
  • Comfort, colour, casual: elastic loop.
  • Dressy, refined, office-ready: Saffiano leather.

Still deciding? Message us on WhatsApp — we reply within 15 minutes and can recommend the right strap for your exact reference. Shop bestsellers to see what other collectors are reaching for.

Back to blog